| A selection of the comments provided is listed below |
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I like the subtlety of this proposal, which draws people onto and along the street, and will provide people with something to think about if they want to be solitary or to comment on with others if they are social. I'm hoping the poem would be intriguing and thought provoking, not overt or didactic, something people could read frequently with pleasure. (John Terpsta's work would be a great model.) It won't add clutter to the street nor interfere with recent local traditions like the street's Christmas display.
This subtle installation would also provide some urban room for one or more larger, bolder pieces to be added at a later time, should the community feel the need for that.
The other two proposals, though interesting and perhaps bolder, seem to me to have more drawbacks. The coloured poles are fun and interesting and would be my second choice, but they would add extra light to the street, not a benefit for everyone, possibly seen as light pollution on top of the current street lighting. I can also see them getting covered up with tattered posters, tape etc., which would soon spoil the effect and require maintenance.
While incorporating the idea of animal life into this 'people place' is pleasing, I don't think the metal signs would be effective in making walkers or drivers give much thought to that meaning. The angel symbol also confuses the idea of urban animals and creatures existing historically in the area. And why no raccoons? Other areas of the city have banners and added signage; this just seems like more of the same.
Thanks for the opportunity to comment. Good public art is a wonderful addition to a city.
|
(Untitled)
Lovely artwork! So inspiring to many young artists. We hope to see more!
|
(hOley pOley)
Will brighten the street and give a great visual look.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Poetry is very unusual as a public art choice. I feel that it is more universal. Long after visual installations are dated and faded, poetry lives on. It is less intrusive, more suble, and makes you think more.
|
(hOley pOley)
This one seems the most original and would make Locke Street stand out, and most reflects the quirky character of this street!
|
(hOley pOley)
The proposal fits in quite nicely with the area.
|
(hOley pOley)
Nearly none, but for want of choice. HP could age well, or otherwise be removed.
|
(hOley pOley)
This art work fits with the trendy street and would look very cool!
|
(hOley pOley)
Great, vibrant installation. Like the lights at night too.
|
(hOley pOley)
Love it.
|
(hOley pOley)
Love the dynamic presence of these poles, and also that they add to (rather than conflict with) the streetscape. Also like that they are multipurpose and can see them being used creatively to brighten special events and the overall Locke St. atmosphere. Nice job.
|
(hOley pOley)
Just love this!
|
(Untitled)
Perhaps more important is widening sidewalks along Main St from the north and Aberdeen from the south to make Locke St more welcoming to more people.
|
(hOley pOley)
This is the most visible of all in all seasons.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Concrete Poetry has a subtle yet classic and intellectual feel. I like that you stumble (literally) onto the words and are encouraged to wander along the street to discover a message or inspiration. I find it very engaging and interactive . It reflects the creative aspect of the street and I like that the viewer becomes a participant in the experience. (This would be my choice.) Concrete Poetry stands out as a leader.
Holey Poley is essential very much like the telephone poles that already adorn the street, except for the holes and bright colours. I do not feel that it at all reflects the spirit of the street. The approach here is more "in your face". It would also seem to take up more sidewalk space which I see as a real drawback.
Unfortunately, this one leaves me feeling, "so what...coloured poles..."
Untitled is too nondescript. The images of birds and animals suspended on poles is whimsical enough but again, there is a real disconnect with the feeling of the street.
Of the three submissions, Concrete Poetry stands out as a leader.
|
(hOley pOley)
We need something that will be fun and attention-getting. The others are interesting but too small in scale to really catch people's imagination and make a statement.
|
(hOley pOley)
Yes. I would like to see Locke Street transformed this way! It is fun, informal, unique and noticeable.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I love the reflective and profound delivery of the concrete poetry. Very fitting with the mood and sophistication of the street. Alice in Wonderland meets Locke Street.
|
(hOley pOley)
As a public art along the street, the hOley pOley proposal is both artful and functional. I like the fact that the art piece has the "visibility", works both in night time and winter season. The series of pole installation will add a new layer of dimension to the existing street context.
|
(hOley pOley)
Love the look and idea.
|
(hOley pOley)
Interesting and unique idea. |
(hOley pOley)
This entry is by far the best means of enhancing the already funky, vibrant and colourful look of Locke Street South. It also serves multiple purposes, unlike the other entries. Hands-down winner. Go for it.
|
(hOley pOley)
The most visual artistic statement from either walking on Locke Street or driving through. The proposal catches one's eye during the day AND at night.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I thought all three projects were strong. I choose Concrete Poetry as it can be shaped to create a story specifically about Locke Street - a pathway that can act as a way finder to take the public on a journey that reflects nuances about the neighbourhood. The project is also achievable within the $40,000 budget. I eliminated the hOley pOley project because the number of “light tubes” that would need to be fabricated to the specifications indicated would only allow two to be fabricated (in my opinion). In order for the project to reach the desired impact it would need a minimum of eight “light tubes” which I believe would have a minimum cost far exceeding the budget. Untitled project also had lovely images but I preferred the depth that I think can be created with Concrete Poetry.
|
(hOley pOley)
This proposal makes the strongest statement and is the only one that serves a functional purpose other than being merely esthetic.
|
(hOley pOley)
Great design concept and creative use of street-scape. Eye-catching and visually pleasing.
|
|
(none)
Too much visual clutter on Locke already for the poles, although as on street lighting I am warmer to the design
Untitled takes the space seasonal decorations need to occupy, and imply we need to replace nature with invention to make our street beautiful.
Concrete Poetry is overdone and confusing if the pedestrian doesn't start at the right place.
We need bold pieces that speak to our current social, cultural, environmental times.
What do these installments represent? How do they speak for our times, our struggles, our pleasures, our principles, Locke Streets place in Hamilton's space and time? They just seem random, although the poetry piece has the most potential in that manner.
|
(hOley pOley)
'The most colourful and vibrant of the proposals, and visible to short and tall alike. Also the only proposal that has presence both during the day and the night. I also like that the proposal has a function that signs and banners can be installed on it.
|
(hOley pOley)
I love this idea. It would have a big impact and make the street look lively and very unique.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the playfulness, and presence on the street.
|
(hOley pOley)
I love this concept. It is very refreshing and I like the idea that it will constantly be evolving, depending on what can be hung from the holes.
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley shows out the most atmosphere. The others are so minor, they could go completely unnoticed.
|
(hOley pOley)
Very unique and imaginative designs and will definitely spice up Locke St. My top choice. Good luck!
|
(hOley pOley)
I feel that the hOley pOley design would be best suited for Locke Street seeing as it will give the street an inviting look with more character and will liven it up with its playful and versatile look. It is vibrant enough to make the street stand out in a creative way and yet it is functional in its different uses. I especially like the lighting feature it has along with the ability to accommodate signages, benches and banners. This design wins my vote.
|
(hOley pOley)
Funky.
|
(hOley pOley)
Although I enjoyed all the submissions, this one struck me as having a lot of vitality, energy, and originality. I often go for drinks and conversations with friends on Locke Street, and now that I have seen this proposal, can practically see it in my minds eye when I'm on the street. I think it is the proposal that will make for the strongest impression for Hamilton.
|
(hOley pOley)
This would be highly visible and animate the street quite successfully. Simon Frank's concrete poetry would be successful in a more subtle way and while beautiful, may not have the impact required (it would, however, be my second choice). I am not in favour of the metal cutouts of animals and birds at all.
|
(hOley pOley)
This is by far the most animating proposal which Locke Street could use. It's colorful, active and engaging at many levels. Best of luck.
|
(hOley pOley)
Great concept.
|
(hOley pOley)
Great use of vibrant colour... Adds a bit of fun to the usually drab city streets.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
It's the simplicity and mindfulness of this idea that will draw people into it. In a world rushed and tight with schedules and timetables, Concrete Poetry will offer the people of Hamilton an opportunity to slow down, reflect, and contemplate what the word means to them. The timeless beauty of words and poetry is the true gift offered in this artist's work.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This idea is so simple and yet so powerful. Words and poetry add beauty to EVERYTHING. Bravo!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think this is a very unique idea and it's great because people can read poetry as they walk along the street.
|
(hOley pOley)
This is a very thoughtful, quiet piece. It speaks (literally) with a gentle voice and asks us to become part of the total Locke Street experience. It is very inclusive. The artist has given careful consideration to connecting the work with Locke Street's history as well as the surrounding community. I find the work compelling and beautiful. And I believe it would be a strong and positive addition to the concrete paths of Locke Street; taking us on a lighthearted journey exploring the street as we go. Excellent!
|
(hOley pOley)
Best one!
|
(hOley pOley)
Love the funky multipurpose of this submission !!! What a winner !
|
(hOley pOley)
I feel that the submission by Philip Toms would best serve the atmosphere of the street. With this bold approach, I believe many people will be drawn to the area to take in its unique flavour. Well Done!
|
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley makes the biggest statement of the three proposals. It is colourful and whimsical as well as useful, and it will make an immediate statement to anyone visiting the street. It seems to scream - this is a lively place - one you should spend some time on - whether it's during the day or evening. I don't believe the other proposals can have the same impact. As a person who lives in the area and who works in the arts (and helps to determine what projects receive funding, although in a differet medium) - I believe we have to consider how well the money for a project is being spent. This project is a perfect example of art form an function. It's splashy - Locke Street needs this! Walking along the street with your head down to read poetry (where is the poem btw) hardly makes one enjoy the rest of the surroundings. What will happen in the snow? The animals - seem dull and not noticable even in the proposal - how do they reflect the eclectic community? What other purpose do they serve?
Choose hOley pOley!
|
(hOley pOley)
Far more colourful than the others.. multiple uses. More modern.
|
(hOley pOley)
Makes me want to go there right now!
|
(hOley pOley)
A vibrant submission which would bring immediate street recognition and interest to the area.
|
(Untitled)
I think that this concept is in keeping with the neighbourhood nature, unobtrusive, diverse, collective, supportive, whimsical, and is a good reminder of how we share space with humans, animals and nature, and have responsibilities to collaborate so everyone can enjoy this unique space.
|
(hOley pOley)
Colour and fun are exactly what is lacking in downtown at the moment.
|
(hOley pOley)
Will elevate the positive profile of the City of Hamilton...this creative, fitting, multipurpose, grand visual will assist to put Hamilton back on the map and agenda of must-see cities in Ontario. Locke Street will truly become a destination place. It will keep people talking about the city, it will be stay in their minds and on their lips.
|
(hOley pOley)
This proposal could be very fun! It lends itself to have interesting lighting too.
|
(hOley pOley)
'I like the vibrant colours, great idea! Suits the street beautifully!
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley is Okee Dokee for Lockee Blockee(s).
|
|
(Untitled)
This one speaks Locke St, Hamilton, Ontario & Canada. It reaches not only people who live in the Locke St area but also visitors & tourists alike, as the images are something we can all relate to.
The design of this entry is simple yet elegant and would not require a lot of maintenance, which I believe is key to be the long-term appreciation of the art work.
I think to any art critic or city planner it is obvious why Concrete Poetry & Holey Poley are not suitable choices for the Lock St area. Concrete Poetry & Holey Poley are interesting projects for another time or place. Holey Poley would suite OCAD on McCaul St in Toronto very well…not the Locke St, Hamilton neighborhood.
|
(Untitled)
I think that this is the most attractive of the three choices.
|
(hOley pOley)
The hOley pOley is both unique and attractive, much like the Locke St. boutiques and shops. It will also serve a dual function, unlike the other public art, which is nice, but doesn't have another purpose.
|
(hOley pOley)
Lovely!
|
(hOley pOley)
I have seen the concrete poetry before, and the metal-cut signs featuring animals are not on a scale with which to make an impact....holey poley shows a diversity and creative level that I think will stand out. The brightly coloured poles make a statement but also retain a functional quality, I really enjoyed looking at the different uses for signage, seating and daily use, and the option of expanding to include lighting standards was brilliant. I think this is a very creative yet functional piece that will add value to the community and its users!
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley is great for YEAR-ROUND visibility. The concrete poetry idea will get lost under snow and slush for 5 months of the year. hOley pOley is bright & cheerful. Just what will be needed to brighten up the street during the long winter months and has year-round practical uses. It should be a winner.
|
(hOley pOley)
I really like the nighttime look. I would prefer less vibrant colours for the daytime.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the expressive and dynamic quaity of this entry, though should this artist be selected, I might review the colours. I think they would stand the test of time if they were more muted or limited in their colour range.
|
(hOley pOley)
'This is a delightful, playful and imaginative street sculpture.
|
(hOley pOley)
Locke Street is a unique area of Hamilton and hOley pOley is a unique presentation that will add to the life and energy of this street. Hopefully, this all-season,multi-purpose enhancement to the street will soon be seen finished and being enjoyed by the many people living in and around Locke Street. The other two propositions have been done before elsewhere and Locke Street is worthy of something especially its own.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Visually I like the stamped effect on the sidewalks as they give character to the area.
|
(hOley pOley)
Quite a unique display.
|
(hOley pOley)
All are nice, but I especially like hOley pOley because the poles won't get covered up by the snow during winter.
|
(hOley pOley)
All three entries are very strong, but sometimes the boldest approach is warranted.
|
(hOley pOley)
I love the colours and the scope of this project, and the multiple ways the hOley pOles can be used to enhance the environment and build community. I especially like the way they change the look of the street, where the other projects, while they have their own delights, are much less bold and vibrant.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like this concept, and I think it allows more variations by using light and whatever is mounted on the pole, both day and night.
|
(hOley pOley)
Love it.
|
(hOley pOley)
I think that this is a no brainer. This is clearly the best one by far.
|
(hOley pOley)
Very upbeat, spices things up! Pretty cool.
|
(hOley pOley)
What a unique and captivating design to add to the street's character. Nice that is has some versatility to the design as well....for the future! This definitely number one for orginality.
|
(hOley pOley)
This is cool. It is ambitious and not boring and predictable and done before look....it is a bit uneasy at first to absorb and the timid will get scared....that's ok, as they will be afraid anyway
|
(hOley pOley)
GRRRRRRRRRRREAT IDEA!!!!!! Love it!!!!!!!
|
(hOley pOley)
Now this is something you can't miss seeing!!
|
(hOley pOley)
In my opinion, there is so much visual clutter along Locke St already, with signs and displays outside of shops, that the poetry and sign figures might get lost in it all. The area near the train overpass is quite dull and grubby-looking and would benefit from the hOley pOley design. it reminds me of the incredibly strong yet whimsical statement that the OCAD has at its front entrance.
It has become an attraction and an easily recognizable landmark in Toronto. Locke Street could benefit from Tom's design to liven up and add whimsy to an otherwise forgettable part of Locke Street. It would sure make a great eye-teaser and announcement for the trendy shops and restaurants that beckon to be explored south of the tracks.
|
(hOley pOley)
Unique and beautiful proposal with cross-generational appeal.
|
(hOley pOley)
Of the three submissions, it is the only one that is bold and memorable. Whether people liked it or hated it, they would remember it. I personally like it. I think the fact that they are lit increases the cool/memorable/different factor AND means that they would be noticeable day or night (the other two would not really stand out at night).
|
(hOley pOley)
This is clearly the most ambitious project and would have the most impact. It is the kind of art that could easily define the street. This would stand out in any print ads featuring Locke St and would also serve as a beacon for anyone visiting the city.
|
(hOley pOley)
A fun and clearly visible alteration to the street which will be much more interactive with the community at large. In my opinion, more suitable than either of the other two entries.
|
(hOley pOley)
What a great way to liven up a drab streetscape, especially at night and in winter. It turns the normally negative impact of utility poles into a positive element in the visual environment. If this option is selected, I would think it would be difficult to resist attaching a metal cutout of a mouse from the third option to a yellow (Swiss cheese) hOley pOley.
|
(hOley pOley)
This proposal is a great modern interpretation of Hamilton's roots as the "Steel City".
|
|
(hOley pOley)
Visually much more engaging than the other two proposals. A bit unrealistic in terms of cost though, keeping in mind the $40K budget. $40K only allows for $2,400 apiece for the 17 proposed pieces. Solar-powered internal LED lighting would be really cool though.
The concrete poetry is not flamboyant enough, but it is rugged, and could be developed in small increments. Perhaps too intellectual. Better suited to a calm, contemplative park setting, not a busy pedestrian mall.
The two-dimensional steel animals need to be larger than life, they do not impact enough on the streetscape.
|
(Untitled)
I like this idea because it is provocative. It incorporates the natural and supernatural worlds, which are both important aspects of our lives. The proposed animal and angel silhouettes are very quaint, fun and quirky, which fit perfectly with the feel of Locke Street. The animals remind us that they in fact were here before us and as the proposal states, they most likely will be here long after we are gone, which gives everyone something profound to think about. The other two are not as thought provoking, even the Concrete Poetry feels a little too run-of-the-mill. In my humble opinion, being an artist myself, I feel that Untitled definitely reflects the character and quality of Locke Street.
|
(Untitled)
I like the idea of having animals as a symbol in Locke Street because, as the artists said, it throws back to the idea that at one time the area was occupied by nature. That reminder is important in a world forever losing its
touch with nature.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I am a merchant on the street; I don't really like any of the choices, but if I had to pick one of the three I think the poetry one would be my choice. I would like to see something that would stand out a little more like little trees or beautiful street lamps, something that would show a little more class. That represents our street. Please don't put the holey poley; I really would not look forward to coming to work and seeing those every day.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think this is an interesting concept to help promote the Literary Arts, which are often overlooked.
|
(hOley pOley)
Great idea.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think this is the classiest of the three choices.
|
(hOley pOley)
Funky and dramatic, yet they don't obstruct or clutter the street.
|
(hOley pOley)
Out of-this-world artist wonderland. Well done Philip. I look forward to visiting Hamilton now, again, in a different light.
|
(hOley pOley)
Beautiful. A real statement.
|
(Untitled)
I like the idea of animals, but I would prefer a more varied selection of animals ~ might I suggest including a dragonfly, a sparrow or starling, a racoon, even a (phew!) skunk? They are all fauna that can be found in this immediate area, as well as the dogs, cats & squirrels. I do like the addition of a fanciful creature as well, but my own preference would be a fairy figure as opposed to an angel.
|
(hOley pOley)
Tthis one is the most original, although I'd like it better if the poles were straight and a little bit skinnier.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Please don't use the holey poley! It is terrible.
|
(none)
If this is the best Hamilton artists can come up with they have continued the view that Hamilton, although it has good intentions, just doesn't stand out in the art world! A poem you can only read when walking one way! More vertical structures to add posted advertisements on! Metal creatures that have nothing to do with the city-themed area...please! There has to be better submissions than any of these. I appreciate the time and effort of these artists but the project still requires more work and this is not the best way to spend the budgeted funds. Please reconsider these choices or we will be faced with yet another "Gore Park fiasco" but just a little further west!
|
(none)
Let the diversity of the street unify the street; don't try to create some sort of forced pattern with poetry or poles or animals. The repetitive nature of all these ideas actually runs counter to what I believe is the charm of the street in the first place. It's not an inspired idea and is the kind of thing that gives Hamilton a reputation for questionable design sensibility.
|
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley gets the most reaction from me - the project elicits a whimsical visual statement, motion, and change. I vote hO pO.
I like the idea that the project has a functional quality, and yet that this is flexible - no one 'has' to dress or use a pole, but can, if they are so moved. Community members can contribute to the concept by coming up with creative uses and 'misuses' of the poles, allowing the art to be co created by its 'consumers'. The artwork then never remains static, capturing the current vibe on Locke which seems to be one of change. Though there is some gentrification of Locke Street occurring, this project helps to rally against that somewhat, protecting the street from taking itself too seriously.
|
(Untitled)
I like all proposals. Thank you.
|
(hOley pOley)
Captures the imagination and has the most impact.
|
(none)
Oh my, how could you say that money is to be wasted on this. Aren't their more important issues affecting that street?
The plaques set in concrete?? Why?? Don't you want them looking in the stores? I can see pedestrian accidents happening. Read it once, done that.
The light pollution created by the standards. Have you no concern for the people that live in the apartments above the stores or the surrounding neighbours. Goofy and not in keeping with the older street atmosphere.
The bunny??? How long before vandals collect them for their stash ?!!!
Why not something like the Bench People as on College St in Little Italy, Toronto; at least you could have someone get their photo taken with them and have a neat place to sit. Try our city artist and sculptor, Gino Cavecchioli, to make you something worthwhile with some true artistic form.
|
(hOley pOley)
Wow. walking poetry; poetry about Hamilton, read only as one walks Locke, which is of course what one does on Locke. wow.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the concept and design...but not so much the colours. Perhaps a brushed steel or just let it rust!
|
(hOley pOley)
I think this installation allows for more growth and active participation from the people that frequent Locke St.
|
(hOley pOley)
This is an exciting proposal that would really create a unified look for Locke Street -- it's fun and colourful and the artist has given thought to uses beyond the decorative.
|
(hOley pOley)
Out of the three submissions I feel that this one brings the most character and colour to the street.
|
(Untitled)
'The metal cut-outs hold a more accurate place in the history of Hamilton than any of the others.
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley is colourful, fanciful, and makes a genuine statement of "This is a happening place!"
|
(none)
Concrete Poetry too invisible.
hOley pOley too gaudy.
Untitled animals makes me indifferent. |
(hOley pOley)
Cheerful, thoughtful, useful. Will require maintenance but it will be worth it. Love the
night vista. Do lights have to be installed on poles before artwork installation for the
effect in front of Locke Street Bakery?
|
(hOley pOley)
I like this only if the colours were more natural/neutral tones or black. Or natural metal colours.
|
(hOley pOley)
The hOley pOley proposal is both fun and practical.
|
(none)
Even though I really like the poles (hOley pOley), why mess with a good thing that really works? Adding any of the proposed art would appear artificial and ruin the natural charm of the street. Locke Street is cool, don't alter it!
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the idea of having light radiating through the holes in the poles - it will look interesting at night. I could picture people from other regions drawn to this visually interesting street. And that the poles will also be used to attach signs, balloons, etc. makes them more than just visually interesting.
|
(hOley pOley)
Love Holey Poley - great in summer, winter, day and night....other options are interesting but more static. Locke street is lively, evolving and holey poley reflects this.
|
(Untitled)
'While the message of this piece is complicated, I like the visual idea of the piece. The idea of concrete poetry isn't unique and I think there are already too many problems with pedestrian traffic flow on Locke Street without having something else to distract people from walking. hOLey POley doesn't seem to fit with the energy of the street, and I think it would be a maintenance nightmare....where there are holes, the public will shove garbage and other not-so-nice items.
|
(hOley pOley)
This proposal will be the most visible and seems to fit the overall feel of Locke St. It will also enhance the street in the evening.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I believe that the concrete poetry fits best within the Locke St community. It is simple, elegant, participatory, accessible to all, and timeless.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
The concrete poetry is a great idea. I also would not object to the Untitled proposal but OMG, please do not implement the holey poley...it is tacky! The colours are awful...it would clutter and take away from the beauty of the street! As mentioned by others, the poles will just add unwanted distractions and obstacles for foot and auto traffic!!! Also, the poles will chip, scratch, dent, rust and be used for postering!! It will get old really fast! PLEASE NO! I am a local resident and highly object to this choice.
|
(hOley pOley)
Wonderful scheme! Colourful, thoughful & refreshing!
|
(hOley pOley)
It seems to hold fun and celebration.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I'm at the library looking at the submissions. Not sure I like any of them, but the best of the bunch seems to be concrete poetry. Not sure if it worth $40,000 though? Thnks for supporting art.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I love the idea of the poetry - will it change periodically to keep it fresh and interesting? Also, could some words be placed on poles, etc. to encourage people to look around while they walk - not just keep their eyes trained to the ground.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I also like hOley pOley a lot.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Having trouble deciding between 1 and 3. It is interesting but I can't envision walkers keeping track of it so I will go with 3, Untitled' although I am disappointed in the options.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
What is the poem?
|
(Concrete Poetry)
The Concrete Poetry is exceptional. Perhaps adding similar words to eye-level space on buildings or poles would be a nice touch. Also add words "journey", "explore".
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think a poem in the sidewalk along Locke Street would be a testament to the creativity and enthusiasm of Locke Street!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think there is a big gap between the subtleness of the Concrete Poetry and the other two very noticeable ideas. Nice had there been something "in-between".
|
(hOley pOley)
Lively, engaging and open to multiple lives.
|
(hOley pOley)
Concrete Poetry: second best, solid but a little precious.
hOley pOley: best, unless people climb them/fall off.
Untitled: dull, attachments too visible.
|
(hOley pOley)
They're all pretty ugly, but at least the poles will be functional.
|
(hOley pOley)
Provides an instantly inviting and intriguing landscape as you drive or walk down the street.
|
(hOley pOley)
Most contraversial. Use of money.
|
(Untitled)
Concrete Poetry in the road is just annoying, and requires you to look down instead of around you.
hOley pOley is OK.
But the animal cutouts are striking. You have the moment of recognizing what it is, and they are like little gems hidden within the streetscape, and animals make us think of nature, and that is a pleasant thing.
|
(Untitled)
I like the Concrete Poetry proposal with the following caveats: I would like to know the words in the poem. Will the existing sidewalk have to be dug up to install the poem? How will the poem be visible in winter?
I also like the proposal for the metal cutouts, but woud like to see 13 different cutouts instead of some animals the same.
|
(Untitled)
I would vote for the poem if I knew what the poem was, i.e. something generally about walking or city streets. I really like the idea of reading the plaques as I walk. However, the poem is an unknown, so I vote for the Untilted silhouettes of animals on posts.
hOley pOley is a unique idea, but far too susceptible to abuse in a public space.
|
(Untitled)
The hOley pOley design is especially awful, and does not incorporate existing infrastructure. The Kanbara/Kelly design is great because it uses existing street elements, extends down most of the street, and keeps people looking up and around.
|
(Untitled)
Concrete Poetry: unknown poem and can only be enjoyed by pedestrians.
hOley pOley: looks unprofessional.
|
(Untitled)
I think this piece is less susceptible to vandalism. I think the hOley pOles would invite a lot of mess.
|
|
|
|
|
(hOley pOley)
fun, imaginative, organic!
|
|
(hOley pOley)
I love the night image of this concept. The sculptural appeal is simple yet multi purposeful. I do however have an issue with the colours chosen for these poles; I think they will stand out as sore thumbs along a very quaint backdrop of boutiques, antique shops and galleries. I would like to see them in flat blacks in colouring or stainless steel.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Concrete Poetry is definitely my number one pick from the three choices available, it is physically clean, the message is easily understood with very little to no traffic distraction. I feel the other two are well done however I do not feel they compliment the area, both have complicated message, mostly I feel they will be an auto traffic distraction which Locke does not need.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This idea is brilliant and a great way to enjoy the art while walking.
|
|
(hOley pOley)
I love the Holey Poley Idea! Very funky and just what Locke St. needs to stand out and to bring in some colour! Especially in the winter months!!!
|
(Untitled)
The poem is nice but the concrete on Locke St is in disrepair and would only draw attention to that. The Holey Poley idea is disconnected from the street level artist and would contribute to an already overwhelmed street scape that is littered by out of level hydro poles and street signs with no overall design continuity. Also one only has to visit other artisan installations throughout the city to witness the municipal government's capacity to maintain these sites. Although powder coat does flex some with impact it will no doubt chip and will have to be touched up with regular paint. They last example is the only real option, it is subtle enough to contribute to a budding art scene and maintenance will be negligible. Also the merchants wouldn't be impacted too much by the installation.
|
|
(hOley pOley)
neat looking and the night/day aspect seems like you're getting 2 pieces for the price of one .. I like the idea of brightening up the street at night however the amount of light coming from the poles at night 'might' make it a bit too 'busy' so hopefully there is some kind of dimmer that can be used to fine tune the light but all and all very neat and would welcome those poles on the street!
|
(Untitled)
Concrete Poetry - done in other cities, not unique
hOley pOley - innovative and eye catching but, telephone and utility poles makes the side walk look too cluttered.
Untitled - eyecatching, can use Hamilton Steel for local taste, long lasting and good landmarks.
|
|
(hOley pOley)
This is a great submission. It's colourful, fun, vibrant and versatile with the ability to hang banners, kites, signs, posters etc.... from.
Hamilton needs more streets that are visually creative and fun. This would certainly bring that to Locke!
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This proposal is far more in keeping with the character of Locke street than the other two. It demonstrates a subtlety that speaks to the slow but positive changes that have carried Locke street into being a social hub without completely ignoring it's commercial nature. This use of an ages old medium, poetry, to engage the person walking on the street, and presented in the Romanesque typeface in bronze is perhaps more traditional than the other two offerings but then the evolution of Locke Street seems to be founded in having one foot firmly planted on "tradition" while the other takes daring steps into the future.
I think that this idea will also engage the visitor, encouraging them to experience the whole street while reading the whole poem.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
The other proposals seem tacky -- concrete poetry looks nicely subtle. Something we can discover while we walk.
|
(Untitled)
As a Locke Street local, I would love to see the are beautified by this project.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
this one is interesting
|
(hOley pOley)
I'd love to see the City make a bold step like this. I also think it's important to recognize architects as part of the artistic community.
|
(hOley pOley)
nice vivid landscape to suit the nature of the community
|
(Concrete Poetry)
timeless. |
(Concrete Poetry)
The world needs more poetry - especially permanent poetry!
|
(hOley pOley)
Hmmm. Having a hard time to pick just one. I am leaning towards the poetry and the poles, but which one?? I cannot choose!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This is brilliant and sublime. Wish it were being done in Westdale.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
The concrete poetry is artistic, and classy.
Please, for goodness sake though, no "holey poley". Hamilton is already weird. And not in a "Toronto" way.
Toronto has moose sculptures everywhere that stand out a little, and other cities have similar. We have DOORS. Common. Doors? really? No holey poley.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Not sure how plaques will be cleanly cut into the existing cement, not easy to make a flush and neat installation in existing cement. Artist might need to clarify this or provide sample/demonstration.
If hOley pOley is chosen, there should be no or minimal light emitted directly upwards - cut down on light pollution.
Don't like the idea of an 'angel' for the pole cutouts/signs, there are no other mythical creatures. I'd prefer a gargoyle if that's going to be the case. If they want to represent the 'street of churches' idea, then perhaps a (non-denominational) contemplative figure
Glad to see this project underway!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This is the classiest and most interesting idea.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
It's simple, clean and unobtrusive. Can be easily disguised if the area is used for filming.
|
(hOley pOley)
My choice for Locke Street public art is "Holey Poley." Locke Street is vibrant and the Holey Poley pieces reflect the funky, creative, and bright atmosphere of the street and the businesses that make it a destination in Hamilton. I think that the Holey Poley piece will attract attention and engage people in discussion. This is conducive to the kinds of places to go and things to do on Locke - bars, cafes, restaurants, florists, library, arts-based stores - places to be social and be engaged.
|
(hOley pOley)
I love this one. The only caveat I can think of is the misuse of the poles by taping ads or promotions to them. How would this be discouraged.
|
(hOley pOley)
The others are ok but way too low key. hOley pOley has a noticeable presence.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Concrete Poetry best reflects the feel of Locke Street and acknowledges the fact that the best way to experience all that Locke has to offer is by seeing it on foot. It is subtle but has far more meaning and depth than the other two options.
Holey Poley is overbearing, gaudy and crowds an already small sidewalk space.
Untitled doesn't really connect with the people walking the street (it's almost invisible from the sidewalk) and is aptly named, because "untitled" seems to be "unrelated" (not sure what the meaning of the animal/angel(?) cut-outs are supposed to be).
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This would be great near the library and Epic bookstore, combines art and literacy
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Although I would love to select a proposal that is both street art AND functional, I feel that of the 3 short listed projects, 'Concrete Poetry' best reflects Locke Street's identity and sense of place. It is unassuming yet intriguing. While I like the functionality of 'holey poley' I find the design kind of of kitschy, and I'm not sure I want to see one of those circus looking, pastel-coloured poles from my front window. I also worry that if one object is trying to do too many things (ie serve as a bench, signpost, light etc) it runs the risk of doing none of those functions well. As for "untitled"... our utility poles have enough going on as is, and these additional squirrels etc seem like clutter. I wish someone had designed some cool sculptural benches, because people are always looking for places to sit and enjoy the street life on Locke. Maybe next time. I do very much appreciate the investment into art in our city! It's what makes good cities great... and memorable!
|
(none)
I'm not excited about any of them
|
(Concrete Poetry)
A subtle and good introduction to public art on Locke St.
|
(hOley pOley)
All three proposals are very deserving, and I would love to see all three installed on Locke Street. But if I have to choose one, it would be hOley pOley. hOly schmOly - hOley pOley is absOlutely fabulOus!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think the concrete poetry is the project that seems to fit in with the aesthetics of the street and it is in keeping with the walking traffic that it is noted for. I believe it will add an extra element of interest to the walk. It will also stand the test of time. HOley pOley looks to cumbersom and not sure of the significance of untitled.
|
(hOley pOley)
Love the potential for public interaction!
|
(Untitled)
This proposal would add whimsy and light to the street; the animal/bird sculptures literally reflect light off the metal, but the whimsical style adds fun and appeals to all ages. The sculptures would decorate existing hydro poles, which have no redeeming features of their own, as opposed to adding more structures to the street for people to bump into. I think the "animals" could be conversation starters and make people smile. Certainly when they are new, people from the community and surrounding communities would come to see out of curiousity. The style proposed for the sculptures is timeless and would not grow weary in the future.
|
(hOley pOley)
The opportunity for additional uses is very intriguing. Not sure about the colour scheme. Shades of black, gray and off-white may be more appropriate!?
How many poles can be created and maintained with the $40,000?
|
(hOley pOley)
I had hard time deceiding between Simon and Philip because I think they both reflect the area so, in light of this, I going with Philip, although I would enjoy hearing what peom Simon will use.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Sounds really cool!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I feel this one best reflects the character and qualities of Locke Street and the surrounding community.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I really love this idea, it makes sense and represents the diversity of the city.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
A poetry embedded path is elegant and timeless!! How wonderful to interject literacy, curiosity and reflection into the every day stroll, or shopping experience. I am excited by the integral quality of text underfoot in concrete...the discovery of art in the "every day" using humble materials (not to mention green!!)...this is a noble pursuit.
There is even the possibility of text hidden, revealed and uncovered in changing weather. This is a celebration of the pedestrian experience and is so very environmentally sound. This work has great longevity and could mature in our imagination the more it is traversed.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I love the idea of engaging the walker along Locke St. It is a street that is meant to be strolled down! Also - there is a lot going on on the street already and I wonder if the other installments could add to visual clutter.
Finding a word on the sidewalk - which leads to another word and then a shop and then a coffee and another word and... it invites discovery!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Simon Frank's proposal embodies all that is Locke Street. Concrete Poetry is thought provoking, creative, insightful, and responds to the participant in a way nothing else could. It allows everyone who walks Locke to create their own story. If a picture paints a thousand words, then words embedded in concrete will create an infinite number of images in the pedestrian mind.
|
(hOley pOley)
What do animals have to do with locke street...
|
(Untitled)
The designs are whimsical and eye-catching without being distracting, or out of touch with the street. they would add a touch, without dominating the surroundings.
I was drawn to the concrete poetry, being a lover of poety myself, but I was hesitant without first knowing the poem. Not all poems are good poems & a bad one written in stone is a very bad thing indeed!
Holey Poley didn't appeal to me at all. It struck me as being out of character with the street.
|
(hOley pOley)
We liked that the poles are attractive colours during the day and at night they light up and beautify the street. They can also serve a purpose to hang signs, banners etc.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
We like this idea so people can actively participate in something while walking along Locke Street. It's too bad that two artists couldn't be chosen as Simon Frank's along with Holey Poley would be a great addition to Locke St.
|
(Untitled)
I actually love all 3 - but think the concrete poetry will be lost underfoot and cause even more congestion.
The holey poley will look fabulous at night - but Locke is the busiest in the day...
soooo I think that UNTITLED is the best suited for Locke Street...
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I love Simon's CONCRETE POETRY. It is so unique and totally suits the Locke St. area. Go Simon!! What an inspiration!! Can't wait to see the finished product!!
|
(Untitled)
1. The Concrete poetry project makes me very suspect, because the artist is not a poet, and we don't know what the "poem" is. This blurring of professional tasks tends to devalue the work of those who make it their business to write poetry. An appropriation of sorts. And this, if not done extremely well, confuses the general public (and the forming children's minds of the neighbourhood), into thinking this is the same as stuff that comes in books. This makes or breaks reputations and public understanding and appreciation. Would a poet do a painting for public grant or project money?
2. The long tall columns are hard looking, and cumbersome for pedestrians to manage.
3. Untitled is whimsical, friendly, appeals to families, and is at the same time manageable for the street-scape. It introduces abstract art into a cartoon-like yet realist sensibility - thus bringing a simple art appreciation to a more sophisticated possibility.
|
(hOley pOley)
This one has the most impact
|
(Untitled)
These metal animal cut-outs would catch the eye of any motorist passing through and might encourage them to stop and park. It is important that the cut-outs be made from a non-corrosive material that will not require any maintenance, and that will stand up for at least 10 years. If this art work does not meet these or similar requirements, we would vote for the poetry set in the concrete side walks.
|
(hOley pOley)
I find the untitled submission to be a little strange.
|
|
(none)
Each of the ideas are interesting, but each is missing something.
Concrete Poetry - lacks impact and does not explain what the message will be
hOley pOley - too many pieces
Untitled - ok, but why animals and a angel?
|
(Untitled)
I was struck by the artist's comments. And the animal figures seem to draw together the escarpment at one end of Locke Street with the lush green at Dundurn Park near the other end. We need that.
|
(none)
Not really interested in any of them. |
(Concrete Poetry)
This reminds me of a similar public art installation in New York City - the 'Library Walk'. It (the NYC work) caught me by surprise when I first encountered it and I was totally delighted. This feeling continued on subsequent visits and I loved the sense of discovery and contemplation. Locke Street is beloved for its eclectic sensibilities and I believe 'Concrete Poetry' will enhance this tone for pedestrians. Granted, people who are not walking will not experience it, so the other two entries would have more visibility, but I don't believe that they have the enduring appeal of Frank's concept. And, are we not trying to develop this area as a 'destination'? So, 'Concrete Poetry' is perfect, as pedestrians of all ages and heights will certainly enjoy it equally and find renewed pleasure in the words upon every visit. The simple words are also accessible for those whose first language is not English and new readers. I like this very, very much - kudos to the selection committee for ranking Mr. Frank's piece in the top 3!
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Concrete Poetry keeps the most with what Locke Street is about. It is simple yet thoughtful and non-disruptive. hOley pOley is gaudy and would probably end up attracting birds and squirrels into it's knooks and crannies. Untitled does not appeal to me at all as it just clutters up already cluttered poles in the area.
My only concern about Concrete Poetry is how it will hold up to salting and weathering in the winter.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Concrete Poetry is a lovely, whimsical idea, in keeping with the street "zen". I think hOley pOley is too faddish and I think the idea of figures leeping off poles randomly is strange. |
(hOley pOley)
This submission successfully achieves a very high impact for a modest budget, an indication of good design. I believe that both "Concrete Poetry" and "Untitled" would go largely unnoticed after they have been installed. Hamilton needs bold visions and large gestures such as that provided by "Holey Poley" It is fun and attractive, and will certainly send a message that Locke Street and Hamilton are willing and ready to reinvent themselves.
|
(Untitled)
I live a block from Locke, and it is a constant source of surprise to me just how much wildlife co-exists with us in this urban neighbourhood. I like that Bryce Kanbara and Brian Kelly's art installations recognize other non-human residents of the Locke Street area.
|
(Untitled)
fantastic idea!
|
(Untitled)
The concrete poetry is subtle and appealing, too. But I like the idea of looking up at the art rather than down.
|
|
(hOley pOley)I like this idea best because it does bring the neighbourhood together i.e. tying up dogs, bikes, etc. I like the lighting aspect coming out from within, and also the lights on it at Christmas. I would definitely prefer the colour of the poles to be more classy rather than the bright, primary colours being proposed. A brushed silver, gold and copper colour would be so nice. It would also tie nicely with Hamilton's history as a steel town, although it wouldn't necessarily be obvious as we're not a steel town anymore!
My second choice would be the concrete poetry, although I question how safe it would be as people would be constantly looking down and may walk into traffic or other pedestrians (not a good thing when you consider how busy it is on a Saturday afternoon). I do like the idea though, and the concept of the poem tying into Locke Streets history.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Embedding plaques in the sidewalk makes the most sense as it won't compete with
the buildings, shops, people etc. for one's attention. It is subtle and tasteful.
I am vehemently opposed to the holy-poley project. It looks ridiculous
|
|
(Untitled)
I very much liked the animal and bird themes of the 3rd option. The 1st option, concrete poetry I liked nearly as much as my 1st choice. I didn't find the 2nd option anywhere near as interesting or welcoming to pedestrians and visitors as either the 1st or 3rd.
|
(Untitled)
The art needs to be interesting and seeable by those going all the way or just a short distance along Locke. It should not be "in-your-face". #1 requires searching to find the inserts, and if not going far, will probably not be appreciated. #2 appears gaudy and false and is not appropriate for a relaxing environment, and is too 'in-your face'. #3 looks like it would be tasteful yet enjoyable to look for the different pieces, with out being gaudy, or distracting to drivers.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Of the three choices, I prefer Concrete Poetry, mostly because hOley pOley and Untitled would probably add even more clutter to an already busy street scape. Questions remain about the type of Poetry or Message itself and the size and direction of the Bronze Plaques.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
All submissions are creative and original, however my personal preference is for the concrete poetry because it appeals to my sense of subtlety, elegance and refinement which, I think is the context that Locke St. is achieving with its cafés, antique shops and specialty shops. The other entries seem more appropriate for other neighbourhoods. Kudos to the artists for their excellent entries.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This enhances the streetscape in a tasteful and interesting way, without adding "clutter" to the area. I think this idea best reflects the eclectic and interesting people who live in and support this wonderful neighbourhood.
|
(Untitled)
Would be a beautiful and classy addition to the street! Really like the idea of using Steel (Steeltown) and images of nature found in our neighbourhood (dogs, cats, bird, squirrels).
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Is there no public art that is useful...ie: benches, seats etc. that would make the sidewalk a place to stop, sit and chat?
|
(none)
'This effort has oviously failed. I cannot believe that money would be spent on any
of these selections. Such "garbage' belongs elsewhere, not on our city streets. Try again
or forget it all together.
|
(hOley pOley)
This is fantastic and playful..
love it.
| (hOley pOley)
great!
|
(Untitled)
Concrete poetry will date quickly. The choice of words will be contentious. Holey poley looks ragged, will also date quickly, and will create a lot of unnecessary noise. The metal animals and birds etc. are more tasteful, more long-lasting in appeal, and better suited to the nature of the street.
|
(Untitled)
I think that the hOley pOley installation is very unattractive
|
(Concrete Poetry)
It's unusual, handsome, and emphasizes walkability.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Mr. Frank's proposal is subtle, beautiful, elegant in its simlicity, promotes pedestrian flow. Simply love it!
|
(hOley pOley)
I liked the bright colours and the size.
|
|
(hOley pOley)
This is the one that has life. The other submissions are cliches. And predictable. Please, let it not be the concrete poetry.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think Holey Poley would be too disruptive and would look out of date very quickly. Concrete poetry is unobtrusive, thoughtful, and meaningful.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
The concept of concrete poetry sounds best, of course it would be easier to decide if the poem was provided up front.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the idea of concrete poetry but the novelty would wear off after you read the poem a few times, and has little to no visibillty for cyclist or motorists (not that we need to cater to motorists). hOley pOley is whimsical and 'keeps on giving' depending on the light, or, at night, depending on how they are lit.
I like the fact that they will eventually be integrated as part of the streetscape and take on various and sundry functions, other than purely decorative ones.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Concrete Poetry is whimsical, thought-provoking and will enrich the streetscape without overwhelming it.
|
(Untitled)
This project would be good year round even when there's snow and ice on the sidewalk. It would also be less likely to lose its charm over time than the poles. A bonus is that this project should be able to be completed for far less than $40,000.
|
(Untitled)
Doesn't make the same statement that the are on Ottawa Street does
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think holey poley is tacky and would take away from the interesting street scape that exists currently.
|
(hOley pOley)
Very unique and full of fun. Every city in Canada needs a splash of colour.
|
(Untitled)
This one is my preferance, although I like the colourful look of the poles on hoey poley. I think that could be incorporated into these animals - by making them different colours, I think it would offer a funkier look. I would, however, like to see the artist redo a few of the animals - I would like to see a bit more creativity in the lines, maybe a bit more cut out work as well.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the fun and playful qualities of hOley pOley. The other proposals are very low key and risk being lost in the fabric of Locke Street.
|
(Untitled)
The hOley pOley proposal is juvenile and distracting. The concrete poetry assumes people will actually take the time to follow the art route, which is unlikely in most cases. This is why I like the animal cutouts. People cycling along the street or just out for a coffee or meal can look up and enjoy them, without having to "invest" major time in the installation.
|
(hOley pOley)
I really like the poetry, but it just doesn't grab you the same way, or have the WOW factor that hOley pOley holds. And the name hOley pOley - how can you not love that??!
|
(Untitled)
The hOley pOley would have been my first choice... but, it looks unsafe when you load the pdf. They are on a tilt and it looks like your fingers could get squished in the can they are mounted in. Also, with them on an angle... people could walk in. IF these looked SAFER... I would have voted for this in a heartbeat.
|
(Untitled)
The holey poles are hideous. The animal cutouts are irrelevant to the character of the street.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I love the human scale of this project and the integration of visual art with poetry. I also like the emphasis on walking through the art--progressing through the piece as one "progresses" up or down a sidewalk.
|
(hOley pOley)
The first selection is too subtle and would require people look down when you would expect to have shoppers look up.
The second brings a spirit of joy and fun and fits with the nature of the street
The third selection although suitable for the environment, (close to the escarpment with all its critters) does not fit with the street and its merchant culture.
|
(Untitled)
The animals are artistic and winsome and a reminder of the other life forms in the city. They look beautiful, and intriguingly mysterious on the poles, as if they are tied to a giant stake.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
It's simple, unobtrusive and really rather elegant. This proposal certainly fits into the area much more than the other two submissions which I find very child like.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Although the other options are interesting I think that the concrete poetry would add a lot of contextual interest to the street. People will stop and read it and not simply drive by. It will help focus people on walking on the street and over the years may encourage others to add their poems.
The other options may have a negative impact on the use of Locke Street for movies/television since it would lose it's 'feel'.
|
(hOley pOley)
We rarely do anything daring in this City. I think a little bit of fun and crazy can really add a street like Locke. Not everything has to be so damn serious.
|
(hOley pOley)
This selection engages the participant both day and night. The other proposals fail to engage during the night. Also it sets the stage for events on the street and can become an abstract network of beacons that identify the neighbourhood beyond Hamilton.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I do not think any of these proposals reflect the character and neighbourhood. If I had to choose one, it would be the concrete poetry.
|
(hOley pOley)
I love the colour and whimsy of the hOley pOley concept! In additon to being creative and unique, this concept is also practical, in that the poles can be used for decoration during Christmas, to lock up bicycles and tie up leashed dogs.
The concrete poetry concept is nice, but would work better in a more tranquil, garden-like setting. It would be lost among the pedestrian traffic and the dynamic store front displays on the street. The metalic animals are charming, but we already have items on the existing telephone poles on Locke - including banners, flower pots and seasonal decorations at Christmas.
|
(hOley pOley)
I think this would provide a unique new look to Locke St!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I would choose the Concrete Poetry first, the Untitled works by Bryce Kanbara second, and the holey poley not at all - it would look awful.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Much cleaner and appealing. Decorating poles gets messy and crowded.
|
(none)
For $40,000 expenditure, I don't think any of them reflect the true spirit of Locke St. My husband and I both are not in favour of the selections. Actually I'm quite taken back at the quality of submissions. Surely there must be something much better than these three.
|
(hOley pOley)
By far the best entry. Concrete poetry would be second and if possible they both could be integrated.
|
(Untitled)
I like the idea of imagery that is realistic but includes elements of whimsy and fantasy -- all part of the "scene" on Locke Street, where people do walk their dogs often live nearby in the adjoining streets, and play in the local parks. I think this project will appeal to children as well as adults, and is artwork to which people can relate.
|
(hOley pOley)
Art Displays should have a stronger pressence, ie: LED lighting. with a distinct theme, related to the area.
|
(Untitled)
My children all love the animal figures, and considering how many children there are living in the Locke Street neighbourhood these days, I think that's an important consideration!
|
(none)
'All three of these are pretty boring and do not represent Locke St. I would prefer none of them be installed and that three new ideas were selected instead. Locke St. is moving towards being a leader in art and culture in Hamilton, it shouldn't have these tired ideas representing it.
|
(none)
What do any of these proposals have to do with Locke Street or the community that lives there?
|
(hOley pOley)
In my opinion this is by far the best option. This concept is creative and bold (like the area) and will also help Locke Street standout.
|
(hOley pOley)
I do like the idea of the Concrete Poetry installation, but I chose 'hOley pOley' because of the dramatic effect it would have day and night. I don't like the whimsical colours so much. I think something more subdued would be better, like flat colours of deep blue, deep green, deep brown, flat tan...natural colouring taken from the sky, trees and earth.
|
|
(Untitled)
Option 3: The animals is the least worst but it is not very original. The poetry idea is apalling -- it isn't noticeable, original or attractive in any sense.
The metal poles are simply garish and ugly.
How about something attractive and original? How can these be the finalists -- there was nothing better than this? As a resident I demand better options or none. I only voted for something other than none to try to avoid the most ugly options as I presume you are determined to do this. It is undemocratic to force people to give up their say on what is chosen if they don't want anything. The current vote is rigged so that opposed residents have no say on what the choice is. If you have any respect for the principles of democracy there must be two questions: 1) Do you want any of these? 2) Which would you find most acceptable?
|
(hOley pOley)
The hOley pOley proposal makes the most impact from a distance and at night.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
This proposal serves as art on two levels both as a texture and as a written piece of art. Will encourage visitors to look to continue to walk to understand the full message or story.
|
(hOley pOley)
artist flair , multi purpose structures that reflect the diversity of business and culture of the street and neighbourhood . a modern design to move forward for a neighboured rich in Hamilton history.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Locke Street is a wonderful neighbourhood walking place. Let's have art that makes us look closely at the street. Let's have art that makes look beneath our feet.
|
(Untitled)
I think that Locke street is quite colorful in its own way and the holey poley idea is a very good idea. But the holey poley idea is too colorful and bright for Locke street. And for the Concrete Poetry, How long is it going to take until someone comes and wrecks it. The Untitled is a good fit for Locke street and out of reach of people who have no respect for art.
|
(Untitled)
I think that the animals will really add the right feeling to Locke but that the city should also consider putting hOley pOley on James st. between Charlton and Hunter or putting Concrete Poetry on Locke st. as well.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Love it!
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Each art project has interesting merits that would add to the community; however the colorful hOley pOley does add to the visual clutter of the street and maintenance issues plus its multiple uses may cause the aesthetic appeal to diminish.
The signs placed above street level can easily be overlooked, and the roughly drawn imagery sometimes make the animals hard to interpret, plus the oddity of an angel in their midst goes against the stated point of the rest of the submission. When were angels regular denizens of the street?
I like the concrete poetry concept, as it refers directly to the key element that makes Locke Street a desirable place - the fact that people walk the streets, enjoying its bounty and scale. I also like the fact that people will interact with the art - by reading it in different directions and forming their own hunk of concrete poetry. The piece is focussed on the ground and human scale and has an intriguing, interactive component -- that's why I think this would be the best piece for the site.
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley is fun, colourful and impactful. Concrete may be torn up for whatever reason and I think untitled can get lost in the shuffle. hOley pOley will be visible through all weather conditions - give you a lift when the skies get grey and the snow flies!!
|
(Untitled)
I like Concrete poetry too, but have to be honest that I don't like the hOley pOley.
|
(hOley pOley)
I think this is an incredible concept for the City of Hamilton. It is a beautiful proposal and it makes a statment. I think the poetry will get lost while your walking and lost in the winter. The poles are a statement and add creativity to the street scape. I can image them in winter and I can imagine they will look great during Locke Street festival with all the people and the beautiful colors. Great piece of art. Way to go!!!
|
(hOley pOley)
Wonderful idea - very creative!!
|
(Untitled)
I think any of the proposals would make a fun and meaningful addition to the neighbourhood. From a public art prespective however, I believe the Kanbara and Kelly proposal may be the most effective of the three. The figures mounted on existing street poles would be very visible, out of reach of most vandals (reducing associated maintenance issues) and add an immediate sense of whimsy and wayfinding. I would however, like to see the figures made slightly larger if possible so they aren't lost in the visual noise of street signs and banners.
Simon Frank's entry is perhaps too quiet and subtle to make immediate impact as a street presence. The idea of a surprise to be explored underfoot is intriguing, but may do better in co-existence with a more extroverted installation like the Kanbara/Kelly proposal.
Philip Toms entry would add a terrfic sense of fun and playfulness to the street but I am concerned about long term maintenance of the installation. I suspect the lower portions of the poles will very quickly become covered in flyers and tagging (human and canine) while the holes will invite insertion of refuse. I also believe that the art poles would be lost in the visual clutter of utility poles and street signs. On the other hand, Toms' proposal would stand well as an anchor or grouping in one discreet and prominent spot...
|
(none)
'In a time significant and increased deficit and debt, this seems a strange idea to me. Not to mention Locke St. is one of three or four notable neighbourhoods in Hamilton that do NOT need help. Spend money in areas that need it - to me the most obvious would be tax credits for residential conversions in the downtown. People from other cities don't make fun of Hamilton because of the steel mills. It's due to our derelict and embarrassing downtown. Let's have some PRIDE in our city!
|
(hOley pOley)
I like that this proposal uses both sides of the street. It is fun and visually stiking. I like that it can be adapted for other uses, not just to look at.
|
(hOley pOley)
hOley pOley seems great and will encourage business owners and visitors on Locke Street to add to it and make it their own. Concrete Poetry is nice but seems like it will make it more difficult to walk there. I don't want to be dodging people on the sidewalk who are looking down, trying to read the poem, and not paying attention to where they are going.
|
(none)
Not necessary - waste of our taxpayers money! Locke Street is OK the way it is.
|
(hOley pOley)
Would add a colourful, artistic touch to Locke Street that could potentially attract more tourism...the night lighting would also create a wonderful atmosphere...
|
(none)
What a waste of my hard earned money!!! This is NOT art!!! These people should get a real job!!! Why not fix up the roads in the west end? Fix the sewers in the east end; go after the developers who don't pay their taxes on time. If the businesses and artists on Locke Street want this stuff, let them pay for it. Every year my taxes go up and City Hall personnel squander it. Let's get back to zero-based budgeting for 2010 and heve every department justify each and every expenditure.
|
(hOley pOley)
bright, unique, creative, visible to the eye as you walk, will add to the streetscape, will unify the look of the street and serve to create an image or identity for the street
|
(hOley pOley)
Bright, colourful and a bit excentric - like the street. Obviously these would not be permanent due to maintenance but a shorter term art installation they are great! Remind me of the spray painted bicycles hung from buildings in Quebec City last summer and the coloured trees scattered throughout London ON.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
The concrete poetry fits with the vibe of Locke Street the best, and provides the most incentive to mosy down the street.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think this idea is good because it shows quality in Hamilton.
|
(hOley pOley)
I think it looks bizzare in a cool way.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I don't like any of the other proposals, the concrete poetry is the best one of all.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
Do not consider hOley pOley...the last thing this streetscape needs in more poles.
|
(hOley pOley)
Hamilton lacks bold art pieces. This is an opportunity to create something exciting, vibrant and continually evolving. I really like the idea that the public can interact with these pieces creating a dynamic landscape along Locke.
|
(hOley pOley)
Only if lighted at night.
|
|
(Concrete Poetry)
i think this proposal is the most interesting/unique. while it does lack a large scale visual component, i think it encourages foot traffic and is the only proposal that creates a destination in itself as well as drawing people to explore the area in context.
i would hope that there could be something added to the final execution that would make it clear what the installation is -- and where it is (signposts, eye-level plaques or a map, etc). while people are bound to discover it on their own (and there is a certain charm to that) it is good to make things obvious as well.
|
(Untitled)
I think this is the best idea. It's subtle and tasteful.
|
(hOley pOley)
I like the big statement that holey poley would make. It will also serve as a tourist attraction because of its uniqueness and the size!!! Love that it lights up at night and is interactive!!!!
|
(none)
This street is unique, very reflective of the vastly different groups that are seen frequent in the neighbourhood. It is more of an "artists" type feel. The holey poley is very tacky looking. It would bring a cheepness to the street. The listed selections I do not feel in any way capture the feel of the street, & seem to be focused on the one side of the street....is this the best we can come up with????? I would prefer to keep options open rather than choose from any of the above....it would be just throwing money away. Are these all the proposals that were submitted?
|
(hOley pOley)
i think it's cool
|
(Untitled)
I like the untitled (Kanbara/Kelly) whimiscal creatures and I think that they will add to the enjoyment and uniqueness to the street. They are welcoming and individualistic as the Locke St itself. I find the poetry too sterile conceptual. The hOley pOley is very unimaginative and uninspiring. The colours will eventually grate on people's spirits.
|
(Concrete Poetry)
I think the concrete art is a great idea. |
|